
Johnson v. Adgar: Fire Into the Crowd, Seize the Crowd | Broadcast Blue® Case of the Week 2026-45
A protest at San Jose City Hall. Bottles, some of them glass, thrown at the skirmish line. An officer with a 40mm launcher and an order to shoot anyone he sees throwing. He fires, and the round hits a young man who threw nothing, carried nothing and was running away.
This week’s Case of the Week is Johnson v. Adgar, a published Ninth Circuit decision from November 2, 2026. The court took on three questions every crowd-control officer needs answered before the next protest:
- Seizure: If the officer never aimed at a person, was that person seized when the round hit him?
- Excessive force: Was firing into a mostly peaceful, retreating crowd reasonable?
- Qualified immunity: Was the law clearly established in May 2020?
The answers were yes, no and no. All three judges agreed the officer violated the Fourth Amendment. A 2-1 majority still gave him qualified immunity, because no earlier case was close enough. Now that this published opinion has decided the constitutional question, the next officer in the Ninth Circuit who fires the same kind of shot may not get that protection.
In this episode:
- What happened that night, and why the jury’s finding that the officer “fired indiscriminately” decided the case
- A Blue Key refresher on Brower, Torres v. Madrid, Graham v. Connor, Pearson, Mullenix and Kisela
- Nelson v. City of Davis (2012), the pepper-ball case behind the ruling, and why the court held it didn’t clearly establish the law for this shot
- Field takeaways: identify and track a specific aggressor, know what your body camera will show and put your target in your report
- Limits: the court is holding its mandate until it decides a separate state-law claim, so the ruling could still be revisited
Get the free weekly LEO LAW Legal Update: leo.law/newsletter
Podcast: Play in new window | Download